Score: 6

"wellll"

submission: "Echo Dreams"

date: September 26, 2008

the 3-D graphics were risky and in the end probably cost you more than they helped, when people watch something, or atleast when i do, i want it to be easy on my eyes, which this was not, the voices were poorly done and if it werent for the subtitles i wouldnt have been able to understand half of what was said, the lack of a storyline can condemn a flash, however a good one can be a salvation, and this although it was hard to watch, was interesting, 6/10 work on the voicing and graphics and you have much potential

Score: 8

"interesting"

submission: Tales of the Scarecrow

date: September 24, 2008

fairly interesting video, decent artwork, pretty good sound quality and i was able to watch it all the way through, although i must say it kind of reminds me of a cheesey movie i once watched called "scarecrow" anyway, nicely done

Score: 9

"well done"

submission: Hoy te amo ++

date: September 24, 2008

although i felt like ripping my eardrums out because this is far from the type of music i like, i can not condemn it for that, the sound quality was good, the artwork was well done and it kept my attention, all in all it was a well made video

Score: 3

"what?"

submission: The Mourner

date: September 24, 2008

the artwork is decent at best and as for the story....well there really isnt one, a guys at a tombstone, says i miss you, spirit says i know, over that doesnt make a story, im not even sure what that makes the music is nice but the quality isnt the greatest, this just didnt make much sense to me and i didnt enjoy it at all

Score: 3

"sigh"

submission: Dance of Lies 2-The Curse

date: September 24, 2008

this was worse than the other one, with that said some may think it odd that this one rated higher than the other, but that is because this was closer to your own story, aside from the brief appearances of the shadow, lilium, and a pic from the last one of this there was nothing that tied it to the video Lilium. Now, the artowrk was terrible, and the voice acting wasnt much better also the english was horrible, which you cant really be blamed for because im guessing its not your native tongue

Score: 2

"this makes me sad"

submission: Lilium-Dance of Lies pt.1

date: September 24, 2008

i cant say im completely impartial in this because i hate when people try to remake something good in a way that you did, you say this was supposed to be the history of the shadow, but its almost the exact same story, simply put this IS a copy, you tried to take Lilium and make it your own but it just didnt work for you, in the end i just hope you did atleast get the original authors permission if your going to say that this IS the past of the shadow instead of "this is how i see its past being" although i do see potential in your art style and sound quality, it would just simply be against everything i believe to give this a good score

Score: 6

"well"

submission: Hanged Man's Elegy

date: September 24, 2008

i have to give you some good points for artwork/music not only was the music good but it went with the video, however im only giving this a 6 because i couldnt understand the plot at all, without the author comments it just doesnt make sense to me at all

Score: 8

"not bad"

submission: GIRI

date: September 24, 2008

Pretty good idea for it, decent artwork, the voices were a little rough though, not ure what you used to record them but all in all it was a good video, nicely done

Score: 9

"nice"

submission: Fairy Sorrow

date: September 24, 2008

although the artwork could use some minor improvements on the people the storyline and music well made up for it, it had a solid plot and very nice music, overall a very nice video

Score: 9

"good"

submission: Do Us Part

date: September 24, 2008

very nice artwork and although the reason for the video doesnt appear till the very end it does explain whats going on, pretty good video